Record Auctions: Is the Watch Market Really Cooling?
For months now, we have been hearing the same thing: the watch market is cooling. Last weekend in Geneva, the auction houses did not seem to get the message.
On 7 and 8 November, Phillips sold every one of its 217 lots and brought in CHF 92 million, or about US$112 million. No live watch auction in history had ever passed US$100 million before. Christie's and Sotheby's held strong sales over the same weekend, which took the total for the three houses to around US$203 million. If this is what a cooling market looks like, we would be curious to see a hot one.
More than one lucky weekend
It would be easy to call this a single good weekend. The numbers say otherwise. Eighteen months ago, the same Phillips sale in Geneva made about US$52 million, with five watches selling for more than a million francs. This time the total more than doubled. Seventeen watches crossed the million-franc line. Christie's, for its part, had the best watch sale in its history, with more than twice what it made a year ago.
The buyers are changing too. At Christie's, 40 percent of the people registered to bid were Millennials or Gen Z. Almost one in five had never bought there before. That is not a tired market living off old money.
So where does the cooling talk come from?
The rumours are not made up. On the pre-owned market, Rolex prices barely moved last quarter, while the number of pre-owned Rolex watches for sale reached a record. For a dealer with a window full of popular steel sports models, it can feel like a slow year.
That is one part of the market, though. Watches made in large numbers behave like any popular product: when there are more of them for sale, prices relax. Rare watches with a real story follow different rules. Nobody is making more of them. The people who want them do not wait for a discount.
To be fair, some observers point out that the very best lots sold for roughly the same prices as in the last two seasons. We would not call that cooling. Prices that stay at record levels are still record prices.
The independents ran the show
Once again, the stars of the weekend were the independent watchmakers: people who make watches under their own name, usually in very small numbers.
F.P. Journe led everything. Thirteen of his watches made CHF 31.8 million at Phillips, more than a third of the entire sale. The top lot was his Chronomètre à Résonance "Régence", a platinum watch with a hand-engraved pink gold dial, which sold for CHF 8.68 million. A Résonance has two separate movements side by side. Over time, each one feels the beat of the other until both settle into the same rhythm, much like two pendulum clocks hanging on the same wall. It is one of the most original ideas in modern watchmaking. Collectors pay for that.
The best example of how fast this market moves came from Christie's. In May 2024, Christie's sold Michael Schumacher's set of five F.P. Journe watches, all finished in a dark grey metal called ruthenium, for a little over CHF 1.7 million in total. Last weekend the same watches came back to the same auction house, this time sold one by one. Two of them alone made CHF 1.536 million each. Same watches, two and a half years later.
Journe was not alone. A platinum Philippe Dufour Simplicity, one of the purest time-only watches ever made, sold for close to CHF 2 million. A unique Kari Voutilainen set a new record for its model. At Sotheby's, a George Daniels Millennium fetched more than five times its low estimate. Younger names are getting their turn as well: a watch by Sylvain Pinaud sold for more than five times its top estimate. On the same weekend, Rexhep Rexhepi took the top prize at the GPHG, Geneva's annual watchmaking awards.
The pattern is the one we described with early Daniel Roth. Collectors want watches made by a person they can name, in numbers small enough that every piece matters. A brand can always make more. A watchmaker can only make so many.
Our view
In our view, the watch market is splitting in two. Popular models made in large numbers may have a quiet year, which is healthy after the madness of 2021 and 2022. The rare end of the market is moving the other way, with the independents leading.
Prices at the very top may pause from time to time. When they pause at record levels, that is not a warning sign. If you have been waiting for the market to cool before buying a good independent piece, this weekend suggests you could be waiting for a long time.
Related Articles
